To Get a Flu Shot or Not?

CDC doctors strongly support it, but others wonder if it can target the wrong flu strains and do no good or create side effects. What do you think?

It's a debate that comes around this time of the year. Should you get a flu shot to stave off a potentially unpleasant illness or—as many people say—does the flu shot create risks?

According to FOX Atlanta and some medical researchers, less than 50 percent of the U.S. population receives a flu shot every year. That trend is bolstered by the growing distrust that vaccinations like flu shots can be ineffective.

Much of the resarch says that it's in the public's best interest to get a flu shot, according to the mainstream medical community.

In fact, Dr. Tom Skinner with the Atlanta-based Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said the vaccinations "are the single most important thing people can do to protect themselves" during the flu season.

Doctors also promote washing hands frequently during cold and flu season as this can be one of the main causes of transmission for a host of infections, including different strains of cold an flus.

Former AJC columnist Cynthia Tucker has this to stay about the immunization controversy, which also extends to other health issues:

Once upon a time, in a galaxy far, far away, Americans were grateful for immunizations. I remember standing in line at my elementary school to get my oral polio vaccine, brought to us by private foundations and government-sponsored (gasp!) health clinics. No one complained. My parents’ generation remembered polio, which crippled and killed.

But times have changed. Few alive today remember the devastation of an epidemic; mistrust of big institutions, including government, has grown; and the Internet and 24/7 cable news casts have brought us more rumors and half-truths than reliable information. So some health care workers are in a tizzy because their employers are requiring them to get vaccinated against either seasonal flu, swine flu or both.

An alternative line of thought warns against taking flu vaccines. The trend's been on the rise for several years. Some opponents of the commonly administered medical procedure claim that vaccines, including the flu vaccines, can lead to can lead to ineffective innoculation and unknown side effects.

What do you think? Are you headed to get your flu shot this season or are you skipping out due to unanswered questions about their safety. Or a too-busy schdule?

The push behind not receiving the vaccine isn;t to be takn lightly, suggest those in the alternative medical community. After all, vaccines like the injection for flu prevention include a shot containing an inactivated flu virus.

Some people suggest that's not safe, or at least counterproductive. Anne Marie Hemenstine, with a chemistry PHD, argue that flu vaccines, which is produced each flu season, is a broad-spectrum solution that target flu strains that are considered to be the most common and serious for that season.

The thinking goes that if the vaccine is administered to people with uncommon flu strains, a patient can still get sick from the ailment or reap no benefits from the vaccine, she said. She advises that there are no reasons to accept innoculations on the flu virus for strains that you are not prone too. Inert materails in the vaccine can lead to other problems.

How do you determine which strain you have? Better leave that to a professionals, and—if needed—a blood work, experts say.

Leave us a comment below. Have you taken your flu shot this season? Do you avoid it because you feel ill effects afterward? Or are you afraid that the flu shot presents more danger than it is worth?

Meanwile, there are a variety of local retailers such as Rite Aid, CVS, and Wal-Mart in East Cobb that allow walk-in appointments.

Brenda L. Gibson October 17, 2012 at 07:40 PM
I received my first flu vaccine in the fall of 2009. I had a bad reaction at the center where I received it. The nurses made me sit with them while they had 911 on the phone. Complete muscle failure the next day which abated within 24 hrs. The next year, 2010, I foolishly received the flu vaccine again. Within one week, I was hospitalized and diagnosed with Guillain Barre' Syndrome. I was completely paralyzed and placed on a respirator for 2 months after which was followed by months of in patient as well as out patient months of rehab. I was, literally, fighting for my life, and I won! Today, I'm left with pain, nerve damage in my feet and hands, and I suffer with severe fatigue, which my Physicians tell me will be life long debilitations. I'm also told by my Physicians that I'm never to receive another flu vaccine. I consider myself very fortunate to be here today,and with only these residuals. Many have not been as fortunate as myself and suffer many more debilitating residuals than I.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »