patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

'Smart' Transit Option Unveiled in Cobb

An airport-style people mover system linking the Town Center area to Dunwoody was detailed for East Cobb residents Thursday night.

 
0 of 0
Get Informed With 'Connect Cobb' Study
The 21.5-mile Maglev system, which would include "Big Chicken" and Delk Road stops in the East Cobb area as well service to the Town Center, Kennesaw State University and Cumberland/Galleria areas, would cost $500 million and would be finished by 2015.
Videos (1)

Videos

The 21.5-mile Maglev system, which would include "Big Chicken" and Delk Road stops in the East Cobb area as well service to the Town Center, Kennesaw State University and Cumberland/Galleria areas, would cost $500 million and would be finished by 2015.

It's the suburban light rail opponent's dream alternative.

A fast rail-like transit system would link high-traffic areas in Cobb's Northwest Corridor with Sandy Springs and Dunwoody.

It would be built at a fraction of the cost and in far less time than the estimated completion of transit projects listed on next summer's Atlanta regional TSPLOST referendum

It is being billed as far more energy efficient than standard heavy and light rail.

And it would be funded entirely with private sources. 

Does it sound too good to be true?

The man proposing the "Maglev" option -- short for magnetic levitation, the technological backbone for transit lines elevated above thoroughfares -- doesn't think so. 

Tony Morris, the president and CEO of Marietta-based American Maglev Technology, unveiled his proposal to a group of around 100 citizens attending Cobb commissioner Bob Ott's town hall meeting Thursday at the East Cobb Library.

The 21.5-mile Maglev system, which would include "Big Chicken" and Delk Road stops in the East Cobb area as well service to the Town Center, Kennesaw State University and Cumberland/Galleria areas, would cost $500 million and would be finished by 2015. 

Compare that to the more than $800 million in federal funding that was initially earmarked on the TSPLOST draft list for a light rail station connecting Cumberland to the Arts Center MARTA station.

Opposition in Cobb resulted in that proposal being substituted for an "enhanced premium transit service" between Acworth/Kennesaw and the Arts Center station. But that project, if approved by voters, would still cost $695 million, with construction estimated between 2020 and 2022.

Like people movers at airports (also think Walt Disney World's Tomorrowland transit system), the Maglev line would be driverless. The route stretch entirely beside Interstates 75 and 285. 

"It's a smart vehicle on a stupid track," Morris quipped. 

He esimated that the system, when fully built out, could serve 60,000 riders a day, and would need 34,000 trips a day to break even. Each one-way trip would cost $4 per rider. 

Free parking would be available at each of the nine stops, with lots to be built privately by AMT and its partners. 

The catch? If revenues fall short of estimates, Morris said communities served by the system would be asked to help make up the difference

Another catch? The Maglev proposal doesn't solve the problem of Atlanta-bound Cobb commuters; the only way to connect to MARTA on the Maglev line would be to ride all the way out to the Dunwoody stop.

Yet Ott, a vocal critic of the light rail plan who recently took a ride on the Maglev at the AMT's test track in Powder Springs, said the proposal is merely that: A chance to explore alternatives to more expensive publicly-funded transit.

"I just wanted to let everyone else see it," Ott said. 

Morris said he plans to conduct more forums in 2012 and soon will meet with officials from the Cumberland Community Improvement District as he begins to gain more public feedback.

Is the "Maglev" proposal a better alternative to light rail? Share your opinion in the Comment Box below.

Related Topics: American Maglev Technology, Cobb transit, Light Rail, Tony Morris, bob ott, and tsplost

Jetgraphics

3:02 pm on Friday, December 16, 2011

Steel wheel on steel rail trumps rubber tired automobiles, etc, when it comes to rolling friction. Maglev trumps steel wheel when it comes to friction. BUT when it comes to power consumed in moving passengers and cargo, steel wheel trumps maglev. Conclusion: Electric powered rail is the winner.
Re: "Light Rail" - LR is a buzz word used by proponents to impress the electorate to use public funds.
And though "trolley" is used in America for streetcars / trams, it really refers to the trolley pole that taps the overhead power line. Most modern vehicles use a pantograph or a third rail to tap into the power grid.

What I would prefer is private sector owned and operated rail based mass transit, whether at grade, subway, elevated, interurban, urban, light or heavy.
Instead of fighting over public funding for mass transit - let's just grant private transit companies a zero tax liability. The only way they can make a profit is to rapidly build the system, and serve the most customers for the least cost.
But since governments are loathe to support freedom and liberty, I doubt that will ever happen in my lifetime.

Reply

Leave a comment